Strategic Gas Stops to Get 4 Counties in Northwest Indiana

Becoming a parent has changed a lot of things, including the time I have to take road trips. I've only taken one other trip since Austin was born. This trip allowed me to complete the counties I had left in Iowa. However, it was an overnight trip and was exhausting for both Victoria and me. Because of this, we concluded that we still aren't ready for me to take additional overnight trips yet.

I fell 4 counties short of breaking 700 total counties on that last trip. With that, my 3-month paternity leave was about to end. I really wanted to reach this milestone before going back to work.

I first wanted to visit some more counties in Illinois since I thought they'd be the closest. I actually found the closest unvisited counties were in Northwest Indiana. Lake, Porter, LaPorte, and Stark counties were clustered close together. I would be able to visit all of them in about 10 hours total. This would be the most practical for a day trip.

I fed Austin and then checked the radar. It looked like I may be running into some turbulent weather.

Weather radar map centered on Belleville, Wisconsin showing scattered rain showers across the upper Midwest region on May 21, 2022 at 6:40 AM

Iowa Smokehouse had sent me a free gift pack, and I decided to save it for my next road trip. I knew I'd be eating well this trip!

Two packages of Iowa Smokehouse products on car seat - Home Style Beef Jerky and Hardwood Smoked Beef Sticks

While the radar showed rain, things were pretty clear in Wisconsin.

View from car dashboard of empty two-lane rural highway with trees lining both sides under overcast sky

It was starting to cloud up a bit by the time I hit Illinois.

Welcome to Illinois state line sign on interstate highway with truck ahead and grassy median

I noticed that gas was over $5 a gallon, or basically $1 a gallon more in Illinois than Wisconsin! So, I was happy I topped off my tank before I left, and I knew I'd have to be strategic about where I filled up next.

Interstate highway driving view with white SUV ahead, cloudy sky, and billboard visible in distance

Besides $1 more for a gallon of gas, Illinois charges tolls. In many ways, it's like literal highway robbery. It costs so much more in Illinois than Wisconsin to literally drive on the same interstate!

One thing I will give Illinois is they have finally arrived in the 21st Century for tolling. They would snap your license plate and bill you later. This would allow you to keep driving without stopping. When I moved to Texas in 2014, I found out that's how Texas did it. I guess this was one positive thing that happened on Illinois toll roads since this wasn't the case in the past.

Blue overhead highway sign reading Open Road Tolling Marengo Plaza 7 with electronic toll gantry

Traffic was thankfully pretty good, and I made good time to Indiana.

Blue overhead arch sign reading Welcome to Indiana - Crossroads of America spanning interstate highway

Shortly after, it started to rain.

Rain-soaked highway view through windshield with wet pavement and limited visibility

The ground was definitely wet when I made it to the Lake County Courthouse. I actually chose the historical courthouse over the new one. The historical one looks so much better.

Historic red brick courthouse with ornate white trim, central clock tower, surrounded by large trees and green lawn

When I got in my car, I checked the radar again. Unfortunately, it was looking like more rain was to come.

Weather radar map centered on Crown Point, Indiana at 10:49 AM showing line of severe storms approaching from the west

My next stop was Porter County.

Modern neoclassical courthouse building in cream-colored stone with symmetrical windows and landscaped grounds

I was soon at LaPorte County.

Romanesque Revival courthouse in red sandstone featuring prominent corner clock tower and arched windows

The question is, "Would I make the last county before it started to pour?" I stopped at the Starke\LaPorte County line to grab a picture. It seemed like the clouds were starting to build.

Green road sign at intersection of 1200 S and US 35 indicating county line between Starke County and La Porte County Expansive tilled agricultural field under dramatic storm clouds with tree line on horizon

I was able to make it to the Starke County Courthouse before it rained. I finally hit county number 700!

Historic courthouse with tall Romanesque clock tower, arched entrance, and ornate stonework in tan/beige stone

It did look like the storm was still brewing, and I'd drive through it on my way back to Wisconsin.

Weather radar map centered on Knox, Indiana at 12:43 PM showing intense line of storms with heavy rain moving through area

I realized I didn't have enough gas to comfortably get back home.

Car instrument cluster display showing Trip 1 statistics: 264.2 miles traveled, 42.1 MPG average, 257 miles range remaining, 63°F

Indiana surprised me with how high gas was there. It was around $4.79 a gallon. This was cheaper than the $5+ a gallon in Illinois, but not by much. I was able to find a gas station that had $4.59 gas.

Marathon gas station price sign displaying diesel at $4.20 and regular unleaded at $3.99 per gallon

I put in $10 (well, $10.01) in the tank and knew it would get me home to $4.19 a gallon gas.

Gas pump display showing $8.01 total for 2.777 gallons dispensed, Marathon and Bass Pro Shops branding visible Car instrument cluster display showing Trip 1 statistics: 264.3 miles traveled, 42.0 MPG average, 345 miles range remaining, 63°F Google Maps navigation screen showing route on S 400 E/N Heaton St toward E Washington St with 4 hour 6 minute estimated travel time

It kept getting cloudier and cloudier. It was pouring by the time I hit Illinois, and traffic was moving slowly.

Heavy rain on interstate highway with multiple vehicles including FedEx truck, overpass visible, severely reduced visibility

I was happy when I started seeing signs to get back to Wisconsin.

Rainy highway conditions with green overhead exit signs and FedEx truck ahead during severe weather

I was getting hungry, and I stopped at an Illinois travel plaza. I see this wouldn't be a good place to sleep in my car.

Green highway sign reading Parking 2 Hour Limit at rest area with multi-lane highway and vehicles visible

I got 2 McChickens from McDonald's. Despite billboards saying they were 2 for $3, these cost over $6. The Illinois Tollway strikes again!

Two McDonald's McChicken sandwiches in yellow and green branded wrappers on car seat

The Illinois Tollway thanked me as I left. Not sure how to take this one...

Clear highway view after storm with green Thank You sign, grassy median under cloudy sky

I was back in Wisconsin soon enough.

Car instrument cluster display showing Trip 1 statistics: 501.4 miles traveled, 41.3 MPG average, 69 miles range remaining, 64°F, total odometer 135,943 miles

I made it back to Belleville with 69 miles to empty!

Car instrument cluster display showing Trip 1 statistics: 501.4 miles traveled, 41.3 MPG average, 69 miles range remaining, 64°F, total odometer 135,943 miles

While $4.19 is still expensive for a gallon of gas, I was happy. It was still much cheaper than where I had been. However, I still broke over $40 to fill my little Focus.

Casey's General Store sign displaying gas prices: UNL 88 at $4.04¼, Unleaded at $4.19⁹, Diesel at $5.18⁹ Gas pump display showing $44.42 total for 10.579 gallons with Pay at pump or prepay inside sign

After the trip, I logged onto the Illinois Tollway website. Driving a round trip to Indiana only cost me $23.90!

Illinois Tollway website screenshot showing multiple plaza toll charges ranging from $1.50 to $1.90, total selected $23.90

The biggest thing from this trip was visiting 4 counties to get me to the 700 mark. This trip was less brutal for both Victoria and me than the last overnight trip, but still a little brutal. So, I may focus on local stuff for the time being.

I know I will have to continue to be strategic with my gas stops and toll road usage in the future. Driving the Illinois Tollway definitely feels a bit like highway robbery. Yet, it does save a lot of time compared to taking the side roads. Then again, the side roads have a lot more adventure. I guess we'll see what I come up with on a future trip.

See more blog entries here